HOME PAGE | |
№ 1/2010
ANTONOV S. 1, SHISHKOV Stanislav Yevhenijovych2
1Association "Ukrainian Stock Traders"
2PJSC Perspectyva Stock Exchange
Determination of the market value of securities: the main problems and ways of their solution
Ekon. prognozuvannâ 2010; 1:67-98 |
ABSTRACT ▼
The authors analyze the world experience of pricing at the stock markets, reveal the gaps in Ukraine’s legal basis, and, based on a comprehensive analysis of the problem of defining the real value of securities at the stock market, they outline the ways of its solution
Keywords:
Article in Ukrainian (pp. 67 - 98) | Download | Downloads :524 |
REFERENCES ▼
2. Finansovomonetarni vazheli ekonomichnogo rozvytku, v 3 t., za red. A.I.Danylenka, K.: Feniks, 2008, T. 2, Mekhanizmy groshovogo ta fondovogo rynkiv i yikh vplyv na rozvytok ekonomiky Ukrainy, S. 332 (p. 4.1. Formuvannia ta rozvytok rynku tsinnykh paperiv v Ukraini).
3. Finansovomonetarni vazheli ekonomichnogo rozvytku, v 3 t., za red. A.I.Danylenka, K.: Feniks, 2008, T. 3, Finansy pidpryiemstv: tendentsii, stan i problemy upravlinnia, S. 96 (p. 2.4. Aktsii ta korporatyvni obligatsii pidpryiemstv yak instrumenty zaluchennia investytsiynogo kapitalu).
4. Mozgovyi O.M. Fondovyi rynok, K. : KNEU, 2001, 96 s.
5. Informatsiia shodo finansovogo stanu bankiv Ukrainy, <www.bank.gov.ua/Bank_supervision/index.htm>.
6. Analitychni ogliady rynku spilnogo investuvannia, <www.uaib.com.ua/analituaib/year_analit_uaib.html>.
7. Richni zvity DKTsPFR, <www.ssmsc.gov.ua>.
8. Informatsiia pro stan i rozvytok nederzhavnogo pensiynogo zabezpechennia Ukrainy, <www.dfp.gov.ua/732.html>.
9. Informatsiia pro stan i rozvytok strakhovogo rynku Ukrainy, <www.dfp.gov.ua/734.html>.
10. Zakon Ukrainy "Pro tsinni papery ta fondovyi rynok" vid 23.02.2006 r. № 3480IV.
11. Polozhennia pro reiestratsiiu fondovykh birzh ta torgovelnoinformatsiynykh system i reguliuvannia yikh diialnosti, zatverdzhene rishenniam DKTsPFR vid 11.11.1997 r. № 46.
12. Kontseptsiia funktsionuvannia i rozvytku fondovogo rynku v Ukraini, zatverdzhena Postanovoiu Kabinetu Ministriv Ukrainy vid 29.04.1994 r. № 277.
13. Polozhennia pro organizatsiyno oformleni pozabirzhovi torgovelnoinformatsiyni systemy, zatverdzhene nakazom DKTsPFR vid 23.12.1996 r. № 328.
14. Polozhennia pro funktsionuvannia fondovykh birzh, zatverdzhene rishenniam DKTsPFR vid 19.12.2006 r. № 1542.
15. Polozhennia pro poriadok opryliudnennia informatsii ta nadannia administratyvnykh danykh shodo zdiysnennia diialnosti organizatoramy torgivli, zatverdzhene rishenniam DKTsPFR vid 11.06.2002 r. № 212 (u redaktsii rishennia vid 21.05.2007 r. № 1035).
16. Vidomosti shodo birzhovykh kursiv, rozrakhovanykh na fondovykh birzhakh, sho uklaly dogovory z UAIB, <www.uaib.com.ua>.
17. Burmaka M.O, Antonov S.M. Osnovni napriamky vdoskonalennia normatyvnoi bazy fondovogo rynku Ukrainy, Tsinni papery Ukrainy, 2008, № 48, S. 13–28.
18. Polozhennia (standart) bukhgalterskogo obliku 19 "Ob’iednannia pidpryiemstv", zatverdzhenyi nakazom Ministerstva finansiv Ukrainy vid 07.07.1999 r. № 163.
19. Zakon Ukrainy "Pro opodatkuvannia prybutku pidpryiemstv" vid 28.12.1994 r. № 334 94–VR.
20. Polozhennia pro poriadok formuvannia rezervu pid operatsii bankiv Ukrainy z tsinnymy paperamy, zatverdzhene Postanovoiu Pravlinnia NBU vid 02.02.2007 r. № 31.
21. Postanova NBU vid 23.07.2008 r. № 211 "Pro vnesennia zmin do deiakykh normatyvnopravovykh aktiv Natsionalnogo banku Ukrainy".
22. Polozhennia pro reguliuvannia Natsionalnym bankom Ukrainy likvidnosti bankiv Ukrainy, zatverdzhene Postanovoiu Pravlinnia NBU vid 26.09.2006 r. № 378.
23. Polozhennia pro poriadok vyznachennia chystoi vartosti aktyviv nederzhavnogo pensiynogo fondu (vidkrytogo, korporatyvnogo, profesiynogo), zatverdzhene rishenniam DKTsPFR vid 11.08.2004 r. № 339.
24. Mizhnarodni tendentsii: rynky dovodiat nadiynist dyversyfikatsii, Mizhnarodnyi pensiynyi visnyk, 2009, № 3, Elektronnyi resurs, Dostupnyi z, <www.uaib.com.ua/files/articles/ 1014/43/newsletter_issue2_february2009_ukr.pdf>.
25. Rezultaty diialnosti pensiynykh fondiv: Robochyi dokument OESR zi strakhuvannia ta pryvatnykh pensiy № 20, S. 8, Elektronnyi resurs, Dostupnyi z, <www.uaib.com.ua/files/articles/ 1014/43/newsletter_issue3_march2009_ua.pdf>.
26. Polozhennia pro poriadok vyznachennia vartosti chystykh aktyviv instytutiv spilnogo investuvannia (payovykh ta korporatyvnykh investytsiynykh fondiv), zatverdzheni Rishenniam DKTsPFR vid 02.07.2002 r. № 201.
27. Lyamec S. Kapital vyvodyat cherez akcii i OVGZ, <www.sta.gov.ua/control/uk/publish/article;jsessionid=0EC855D026ECB 53D3627A2CA17CCFFFB?art_id=155407&cat_id=90619>.
28. Maksimchuk N, Nepryakhina N. Bol`shaya uborka, Kommersant, Ukraina, 2010, № 27, <www.kommersant.ua/ doc.html?DocID=1323466& IssueId=7000370>.
29. SEC ne gotova miniaty pravylo obliku aktyviv za rynkovoiu tsinoiu, ale yde na postupky, <bin.com.ua/templates/ news_article_big.shtml?id=82696>.
30. Pryntsypy otsinky aktyviv za rynkovoiu vartistiu vyklykav dyskusiiu na konferentsii z investytsiynykh pytan, Mizhnarodnyi pensiynyi visnyk, 2009, № 3, <www.uaib.com.ua/files/articles/1014/ 43/newsletter_issue3_ march2009_ua.pdf>.
31. Typologii legalizatsii (vidmyvannia) dokhodiv, oderzhanykh v rezultati zdiysnennia finansovykh operatsiy z nelikvidnymy tsinnymy paperamy, zatverdzheni nakazom Derzhavnogo komitetu finansovogo monitoryngu Ukrainy vid 20.12.2007 r. № 230.
32. Majorov S.I, Oksenojt G.K. Rynok gosudarstvennykh cennykh bumag: instrumenty i organizaciya, M. : YYTs "Statystyka Rossyy", 2006, 311 s.
33. Vidkrytyi lyst Asotsiatsii UAIB do Asotsiatsii PFTS vid 23.09.2008 r., <www.uaib.com.ua/files/articles/629/65_4.doc>.
34. WFE Annual Reports, WFE Focus, <www.worldexchanges.org>.
35. Natsionalni standarty № 1 "Zagalni zasady otsinky mayna i maynovykh prav", № 2 "Otsinka nerukhomogo mayna", № 3 "Otsinka tsilisnykh maynovykh kompleksiv", № 4 "Otsinka maynovykh prav intelektualnoi vlasnosti", zatverdzheni vidpovidno postanovamy Kabinetu Ministriv Ukrainy vid 10.09.2003 r. № 1440, vid 28.10.2004 r. № 1442, vid 29.11.2006 r. № 1655, vid 03.10.2007 r. № 1185.
36. Zakon Ukrainy "Pro aktsionerni tovarystva" vid 17.09.2008 r. № 514VI.
№ 2/2019
SHISHKOV Stanislav Yevhenijovych1
1PJSC Perspectyva Stock Exchange
Structural-functional deformations of the stock market in Ukraine: macro- and micro-measurements
Ekon. prognozuvannâ 2019; 2:22-66 | https://doi.org/10.15407/eip2019.02.022 |
ABSTRACT ▼
The article highlights the factors of the classification of issuers and their securities (forms of circulation and admission to trading, listing, publicity, type of offering, liquidity, objectivity of pricing) in the context of determining the reasons for the limited number of instruments in Ukraine’s regulated market and signs of its unattractiveness for issuers and investors. The author defines peculiarities of the formation and structure of investment portfolios of financial institutions and other investors (in comparison with international indicators) and difficulties of the valuation and diversification of assets. It has been revealed that a sharp reduction in the number of issuers and financial intermediaries (through variable legislation, increased regulatory requirements and controversial enforcement) led to a reduction in liquidity and competition, an increase in transaction costs, and did not contribute to market development, its infrastructure, and the objectivity of pricing.
The emphasis is on the conventionalities of market benchmarks (stock indexes of shares, total capitalization) in Ukraine due to the limited financial instruments, lack of public companies, scanty liquidity, high volatility and artificiality of pricing. Indicated various signs of illiquidity of Ukraine’s regulated stock market in comparison with world trading platforms (first of all, in relation to shares), as well as reasons of irregularity of the trades, mainly the purpose oriented conclusion of agreements, absence of active market and actual prices (in particular, due to unsatisfactory regulation of exchange pricing).
However, it is worth emphasizing the significant role of government bonds that differ from other securities in Ukraine in that they have increased liquidity, strong investor demand, more predictability and price adequacy, which is a sufficiently anticipated factor for an underdeveloped stock market.
The author highlights peculiarities and problems of pricing in the underdeveloped stock market, which considerably complicate the task of counteracting market abuse, in particular due to total illiquidity, the absence of contradiction in the implementation of international practice, and subjectivity of the existing regulatory criteria for the detection of manipulation.
Keywords: stock market, stock exchange, trading volume, securities, asset pticing, market manipulation, market abuse, public company, public offering, listing, squeeze-out
JEL: G12, G14, G15, G18, K22
Article in Ukrainian (pp. 22 - 66) | Download | Downloads :1775 |
REFERENCES ▼
2. Changing the legislation on ICI: slow down (2016, June 15). Stock World. Retrieved from www.stockworld.com.ua/ru/news/izmienieniie-zakonodatielstva-ob-isi-spieshit-miedlienno [in Russian].
3. Korol, Viacheslav. (2017, July 25). Listing in Ukrainian: beat yours so that people are afraid. Ekonomichna pravda – Economic truth. Retrieved from www.epravda.com.ua/columns/2017/07/25/627444/ [in Ukrainian].
4. Annual report of the National Commission on Securities and Stock Market for 2017. Retrieved from www.nssmc.gov.ua/documents/rtchniy-zvt-nktspfr-za-2017-rk/ [in Ukrainian].
5. Annual report of the National Depository of Ukraine for 2017. Retrieved from csd.ua/images/stories/pdf/CSD_report2017.pdf [in Ukrainian].
6. Involvement of the population in the investment process (2017, April 24). BCS Express. Retrieved from bcs-express.ru/novosti-i-analitika/vovlechennost-naseleniia-mira-v-investitsionnyi-protsess [in Russian].
7. UX Review (2017). No. 27. Retrieved from fs.ux.ua/f/2325/27-ux-review-done.pdf [in Russian].
8. Analytical review of the asset management market for 2017. Ukrainian Association of Investment Business. Retrieved from www.uaib.com.ua/analituaib/publ_ici_quart/266015.html [in Ukrainian].
9. Results of the development of the system of non-state pension provision as of December 31, 2017. National Commission, which carries out state regulation in the field of financial services markets. Retrieved from www.nfp.gov.ua/files/17_Dep_Repetska/NPF_IV_kv%202017.pdf [in Ukrainian].
10. Bonded domestic government loans in circulation, for the sum of principal debt. National Bank of Ukraine. Retrieved from bank.gov.ua/files/T-bills_debt.xls [in Ukrainian].
11. World Economic Outlook Database. Retrieved from www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/weo/2018/01/weodata/weoselgr.aspx
12. Investment Company Fact Book. A Review of Trends and Activities in the Investment Company Industry (2018, May). Investment Company Institute. Retrieved from www.ici.org/pdf/2018_factbook.pdf
13. Global pension assets study (2018, February). Willis Towers Watson, Thinking Ahead Institute. Retrieved from www.willistowerswatson.com/-/media/WTW/Images/Press/2018/01/Global-Pension-Asset-Study-2018-Japan.pdf
14. Sovereign Wealth Fund Renkings (2018, August). Sovereign Wealth Fund Institute. Retrieved from www.swfinstitute.org/sovereign-wealth-fund-rankings/
15. Securities in the portfolio of deposit-taking corporations. National Bank of Ukraine. Retrieved from bank.gov.ua/files/3.4-Securities_assets.xls [in Ukrainian].
16. Report on financial structures (2017, October). European Central Bank. Retrieved from www.ecb.europa.eu/pub/pdf/other/reportonfinancialstructures201710.en.pdf
17. Information note (2018, May16). Guarantee Fund for Individuals Deposits. Retrieved from www.fg.gov.ua/about/prezentatsiji-fondu/37420-70protsent-tsinnykh-paperiv-shcho-oblikovuiutsia-na-balansi-neplatospromozhnykh-bankiv-smittievi-i-vykorystovuvalys-dlia-vyvedennia-likvidnykh-aktyviv [in Ukrainian].
18. Results of the activity of insurance companies for 2017. National Commission, which carries out state regulation in the field of financial services markets. Retrieved from www.nfp.gov.ua/files/OgliadRinkiv/SK/2017_rik/sk_%202017.pdf [in Ukrainian].
19. OECD (2017). Institutional Investors Statistics. doi: doi.org/10.1787/instinv-2017-2-en
20. OECD (2018). Pension Markets in Focus. Retrieved from www.oecd.org/daf/fin/private-pensions/Pension-Markets-in-Focus-2018.pdf
21. Tkach, Oleksandr (2017, September 22). Retirement lessons for Ukraine. Polish experience. Dzerkalo tyzhnia. Ukraina – Mirror of the week. Ukraine. Retrieved from dt.ua/macrolevel/pensiyni-uroki-dlya-ukrayini-polskiy-dosvid-254926_.html [in Ukrainian].
22. Ovcharenko, Hryhorij 2018, October 30). The absence of a stock market in Ukraine is a 'plus' for pension reform. Ministry of Finance of Ukraine. Retrieved from minfin.com.ua/ua/2018/10/30/35392383/ [in Ukrainian].
23. Honcharov, Oleksandr (2019, March 18). Old rules in the economy do not work, no new ones. And one could learn in Poland. 112.ua. Retrieved from ua.112.ua/mnenie/stari-pravyla-v-ekonomitsi-ne-pratsiuiut-novykh-poky-nemaie-a-mozhna-bulo-b-povchytysia-u-polshchi-484354.html [in Ukrainian].
24. Government Pension Fund Global (2019, February). Norges bank. Retrieved from www.nbim.no/contentassets/02bfbbef416f4014b043e74b8405fa97/annual-report-2018-government-pension-fund-global.pdf
25. Number of legal entities by organizational forms. State Statistics Service of Ukraine. Retrieved from www.ukrstat.gov.ua/edrpoy/ukr/EDRPU_2018/ks_opfg/ks_opfg_0118.htm [in Ukrainian].
26. Indicators of the banking system. National Bank of Ukraine. Retrieved from bank.gov.ua/control/uk/publish/article?art_id=34661442 [in Ukrainian].
27. Wyman, Oliver. (2015, September). Regional Central Counterparty: a solution for Central and Easter Europe. European Bank for Reconstruction and Development. Retrieved from www.ebrd.com/documents/comms-and-bis/regional-central-counterparty.pdf
28. Khromaiev, Tymur (2018, December 26). Many cry 'treason' and 'shame' on Facebook, but they can not prove their own right. Financial Club. Retrieved from finclub.net/ua/analytics/tymur-khromaiev-bahato-khto-krychyt-zrada-i-hanba-u-feisbutsi-ale-dovodyty-vlasnu-pravotu-ne-vmiiut.html [in Ukrainian].
29. MSCI Global Market Accessibility Review (2018, June). Retrieved from www.msci.com/documents/1296102/1330218/MSCI_Global_Market_Accessibility_Review_June_2018_%28FINAL%29.pdf/04dd3b70-487a-8395-912c-89a202b5b4fa
30. Market capitalization of listed domestic companies (current US$). Stock market capitalization to GDP. World Bank, Development Research Group. Retrieved from data.worldbank.org/indicator/CM.MKT.LCAP.CD, databank.worldbank.org/reports.aspx?source=1250&series=GFDD.DM.01
31. The volumes of bonds trading in Ukraine are comparable to European ones (2018, February 06). FinPost. Retrieved from finpost.com.ua/news/6975 [in Ukrainian].
32. Shyshkov, S.Ye. (2019). Oligarchism as a factor in the institutional deformation of the stock market in Ukraine. Ukr. Socìum – Ukrainian society, 2(69), 84-96. doi: doi.org/10.15407/socium2019.02.084 [in Ukrainian].
№ 1/2020
SHISHKOV Stanislav Yevhenijovych1
1PJSC Perspectyva Stock Exchange
THE RESUMPTION OF CONFIDENCE IN THE UKRAINIAN STOCK MARKET: IS IT ENOUGH TO TIGHTEN SANCTIONS FOR MARKET ABUSE?
Ekon. prognozuvannâ 2020; 1:63-84 | https://doi.org/10.15407/eip2020.01.063 |
ABSTRACT ▼
The article assesses the effectiveness of counteracting abuse on the Ukrainian stock market. It has been revealed that the problem of improper legislative registra-tion of counteraction to abuses in the stock market entails unsystematic and biased enforcement by the regulator (NSSMC). The author highlights that the proposed im-plementation of the requirements of MAR (Market Abuse Regulation) and MAD (Market Abuse Directive) to the national legislation is inadequate both in the context of the market\\\'s functional role in the economy and in the context of the unjustified extension of the regulator\\\'s powers. It has been stated that ignoring these issues at the level of prospective legislation will not increase confidence in the stock market and will block incentives for its development.
It has been substantiated that the introduction of strict prohibitive norms into na-tional legislation to counteract abuses in the stock market based on the implementa-tion of the European approach should be as detailed as possible, unambiguous, and consistent with the immature state of the market. At the same time, prohibitive norms should be an integral part of systemic steps aimed at improving the quality of the market, and in its absence - a vector to stimulate development. It is necessary that in the conditions of market immaturity and the actual absence of individual segments, the strict prohibitions for abuse of market participants should be applied carefully and accompanied by the regulator\\\'s symmetrical responsibility in case of insufficient substantiation and subjectivity of law enforcement.
Keywords:stock market, stock exchange, securities, public company, public offering, listing, information asymmetry, market manipulation, market abuse, insider dealing
JEL: G12, G14, G18, K22
Article in Ukrainian (pp. 63 - 84) | Download | Downloads :653 |
REFERENCES ▼
2. AUFT, UAIB, PARD and Association "Exchange and Electronic Sites" ask the President of Ukraine to pay attention to the activities of NCSSMC. Retrieved from aust.com.ua/ NewsView.aspx?news=4576 [in Ukrainian].
3. Report on the implementation of the Comprehensive Program for Development of the Financial Sector of Ukraine until 2020 for 2018. Retrieved from www.nssmc.gov.ua/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/%D0%97%D0%B2%D1%96%D1%82-%D0%BF%D0%BE-%D0%9A%D 0%9F-2020-%D0%B7%D0%B0-2018 -%D1%80%D1%96%D0%BA-003.pdf [in Ukrainian].
4. Bielkin, L. (2018, December 3). The NCSSMC requires telepathic capabilities from securities traders. Stock World – StockWorld. Retrieved from www.stockworld.com.ua/ru/column/ nktspfr-vimaghaie-vid-torghovtsiv-tsinnimi-papierami-tieliepatichnikh-zdibnostiei [in Ukrainian].
5. Kohut, I. (2016, December 1). Domestic government bonds are achievements, but there are nuances. NV-Bisnes – NT-Business. Retrieved from nv.ua/ukr/biz/experts/ovdp-ye-dosyagnennya-ale-ye-nyuansi-300497.html [in Ukrainian].
6. Zaruts'ka, O.P. (2018). Domestic government bonds in Ukraine: pricing features in an imperfect market. Ukr. socìum – Ukrainian society, 1, 74-94.
doi.org/10.15407/socium2018.01.074 [in Ukrainian].
7. Zaruts'ka, O.P. (2018). Substantiation of possibility of introduction of the system of analysis of the regulated stock market. Problemy ekonomiky – Problems of economy, 2, 304-309. Retrieved from irbis-nbuv.gov.ua/cgi-bin/irbis_nbuv/cgiirbis_64.exe?C21COM=2&I21DBN=UJRN&P21DBN =UJRN&IMAGE_FILE_DOWNLOAD=1&Image_file_name=PDF/Pekon_2018_2_41.pdf [in Ukrainian].
8. Koshovyj, O.H., Tertyshnyk, V.M., Shelud'ko, N.M. (Eds.). (2019). Capital Market Abuse: Economic and Legal Aspects. Dnipro: Lira [in Ukrainian].
9. Draft Law on Amendments to Certain Legislative Acts of Ukraine on Simplification of Investment Attraction and Introduction of New Financial Instruments, No. 2284 of 17.10.2019. Retrieved from w1.c1.rada.gov.ua/pls/zweb2/webproc4_1?pf3511=67117 [in Ukrainian].
10. Directive 2008/26 / EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11 March 2008 amending Directive 2003/6 / EC on insider dealing and market manipulation (abuse of the market) in respect of the powers conferred on the Commission. Retrieved from minjust.gov.ua/m/str_45895 [in Ukrainian].
11. Indicative translation plan for the EU acquis in 2019-2020. Retrieved from www.kmu.gov.ua/diyalnist/yevropejska-integraciya/perekladi-aktiv-acquis-yes/oriyentovnij-plan-perekladu-aktiv-acquis-yes-na-2019-2020-roki [in Ukrainian].
12. Credit Suisse Research Institute (2019, October). Global Wealth Report 2019. Retrieved from www.credit-suisse.com/media/assets/corporate/docs/about-us/research/publications/global-wealth-databook-2019.pdf
13. Code of Ukraine on Administrative Offenses of 07.12.1984 № 8073-X. Retrieved from zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/80731-10 [in Ukrainian].
14. Law of Ukraine "On State Regulation of the Securities Market in Ukraine" of 30.10.1996 № 448/96-ВР. Retrieved from zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/448/96-%D0%B2%D1%80 [in Ukrainian].
15. Task-broker appealed to the Verkhovna Rada for suspending the license by the Securities and Exchange Commission (2019, June 25). Mind.UA – Mind.UA. Retrieved from mind.ua/news/20198925-task-broker-zvernuvsya-do-verhovnoyi-radi-cherez-zupinku-licenziyi-nackomisieyu-z-cinnih-paperiv [in Ukrainian].
16. Schmid, L., Klein, T. (2003). Debt vs. Equity and Asymmetric Information: A Review. The Financial Review, 37: 3, 317-349.
doi.org/10.1111/1540-6288.00017
17. Shyshkov, S.Ye. (2019). Structural and functional deformations of the stock market in Ukraine: macro- and micro-dimensions. Ekon. prognozuvannâ – Economy and forecasting, 2, 22-66. doi.org/10.15407/eip2019.02.022 [in Ukrainian].
18. Shyshkov, S.Ye. (2011). Stock Exchanges of Ukraine: Testing the Crisis. Kyiv: Vydavnychyj dim “Kyievo-Mohylians'ka akademiia” [in Ukrainian]
19. Blakhn'o-Pazhykh, A. (2018). Laws are not void, many factors influence their interpretation. Yurydychna hazeta – Legal newspaper, 41. Retrieved from yur-gazeta.com/interview/zakoni-ne-diyut-u-porozhnechi-na-yih-tlumachennya-vplivae-bagato-chinnikiv.html [in Ukrainian].
№ 2/2020
SHELUDʹKO Nataliya 1, SHISHKOV Stanislav Yevhenijovych2
1Ptoukha Institute for Demography and Social Studies of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine
2PJSC Perspectyva Stock Exchange
INSTITUTIONS OF COLLECTIVE INVESTMENT IN UKRAINE: SCALE AND CONSEQUENCES OF INVESTMENT DYSFUNCTION
Ekon. prognozuvannâ 2020; 2:120-138 | https://doi.org/10.15407/eip2020.02.120 |
ABSTRACT ▼
The development of collective investment institutions (CIIs) in Ukraine is characterized by rather ambiguous and stable trends, which at first glance do not have any objective economic basis. The dynamics of CIIs activities in Ukraine demonstrates their steady invulnerability to the crises in the global and national economy, maintaining positions (in quantity terms) against the background of reduced number of both professional stock market participants and other institutional investors, and despite the decrease in the financial instruments in circulation, and the gradual formation in public consciousness of a neutral negative view of the functioning of the national stock market. The authors’ assumption that the key to such institutional viability consists in the tax preferences for the CIIs, which is confirmed by the analysis. It is noted that in this case both the economic sense and the declared "collectivity" of this investment institution are distorted.
The use of CIIs solely to ease the tax burden, with gross legal and tax violations creates risks for both the beneficiaries of such tax schemes and for the very existence of the institution. The specificity of "investment areas" outside the stock market, the highly conditional performance of the function of accumulation of investment resources and, correspondingly, the profanation of the CIIs’ issuer function, in particular as to the fair distribution of investment income, distortions of the essence of the ideology of collective investment in combination with extremely loyal regulation on the part of the NSSMC all presently call into question the entire possibility of considering CIIs as a full-fledged component of the stock market.
Keywords:stock market, stock exchange, securities, collective investment institutions, investment funds, institutional investors, financial institutions
JEL: G14, G23, G28, K22
Article in Ukrainian (pp. 120 - 138) | Download | Downloads :621 |
REFERENCES ▼
2.Nosova, Ye.A., Mohhe, D.B. (2017). Current state and prospects of venture investment funds in Ukraine. Efektyvna ekonomika – Efficient economy, 3. Retrieved from www.economy.nayka.com.ua/?op=1&z=5491 [in Ukrainian].
3.Olejnikov, A. Venture funds in Ukraine: intra-corporate optimization or high-tech breakthrough? Invenrure. Investicionnaja analitika – Inventory. Investment analytics. Retrieved from inventure.com.ua/analytics/formula/venchurnye-fondy-v-ukraine-vnutrikorporativnaya-optimizaciya-ili-vysokotehnologicheskij-proryv [in Russian].
4.Ivanchenko, A., Ustymenko, A., Mykhajlenko, D. (2016). CIIs as a means of tax optimization. Bukhhalteriia – Accounting, 51 (1246), 17-19 [in Ukrainian].
5.Yarysh, O.V., Tsynovnyk, A.Ye. (2018). Optimization of the tax burden of mutual investment institutions and their investors: domestic and foreign experience. Naukovyj visnyk Poltavs'koho universytetu ekonomiky i torhivli – Scientific Bulletin of Poltava University of Economics and Trade, 5(90), 119-124 [in Ukrainian].
6.Lutsenko, I.S., Khomutenko, V.P. (2016). Modern mechanism of taxation of mutual investment institutions and their participants. Hlobal'ni ta natsional'ni problemy ekonomiky – Global and national economic problems, 10, 835-840 [in Ukrainian].
7.Decree of the President of Ukraine "On Investment Funds and Investment Companies" dated 19.02.1994 № 55/94. U Retrieved from zakon.rada.gov.ua/ [in Ukrainian].
8.Law of Ukraine "On Joint Investment Institutions" dated 05.07.2012 № 5080-VI as amended. Retrieved from zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/ [in Ukrainian].
9.Annual reports of the NSSMC. Retrieved from www.nssmc.gov.ua/reports/ [in Ukrainian].
10.Quarterly and annual reviews of the asset management market / UAIB. Retrieved from www.uaib.com.ua/analituaib/publ-ici-quart [in Ukrainian].
11.Tax Code of Ukraine dated 02.12.2010 №2755-VI as amended. Retrieved from zakon2.rada.gov.ua/laws/ [in Ukrainian].
12.Musiienko, N., Baranovs'ka, S. (2020, January 16). Taxation of mutual investment institutions: benefits of the tool and risks for developers. KPMG Law Ukraine. Liha ZAKON – League LAW. URL: biz.ligazakon.net/ua/analitycs/192392_opodatkuvannya-nstitutv-splnogo-nvestuvannya-perevagi-nstrumentu-ta-riziki-dlya-zabudovnikv [in Ukrainian].
№ 1/2021
SHISHKOV Stanislav Yevhenijovych1
1PJSC Perspectyva Stock Exchange
PROSPECTS AND LIMITATIONS IN THE MODERNIZATION OF SECURITIES SETTLEMENT OPERATIONS IN UKRAINE
Ekon. prognozuvannâ 2021; 1:88-126 | https://doi.org/10.15407/eip2021.01.088 |
ABSTRACT ▼
The article points to the critically insufficient compliance of Ukraine’s stock market infrastructure with the relevant international recommendations, first of all in the segment of securities settlements. The author states that despite the creation of market infrastructure in Ukraine and the possibility to avoid problems related to the evolutionary errors, the market participants face numerous difficulties, such as risks in legal empowerment and in the activities of key infrastructure actors, limited competition, excessive transaction costs, ongoing defragmentation of the system of depository accounting, as well as inconvenience and limitations of the existing risk management systems.
The study on the evolution of securities settlement models in Ukraine revealed that the radical reform of infrastructure in 2013 led to contradictory consequences, in particular, the abuse by the settlement bank and the central counterparty of its monopolistic positions, active participation of this monopolist in high-profile market abuse, stagnation in clearing and settlement technologies, and a slowdown in the development of the derivatives market. It was found that, despite lengthy discussions, the updated legislation in the field of organized capital markets, which is designed to implement a number of EU laws and should enter into force in 2021, does not really rectify the problems in the existing infrastructure, in particular due to a rather dubious proposed procedure of securities settlement and conservation for a few more years of the monopoly in the field of settlement and clearing services. It is substantiated that Ukraine has constructive practical experience and skills that can allow to implement the best international standards for building a system of cash settlements in "central bank money", organically integrated into Ukrainian payment system and able to adapt to European payment systems.
Keywords:Financial market infrastructure, stock market, stock exchange, securities, Central securities depository (CSD), Central counterparty (CCP), clearing, Delivery versus payment (DvP), payment system, Securities settlement system
JEL: G21, G28, G32, K22
Article in Ukrainian (pp. 88 - 126) | Download | Downloads :420 |
REFERENCES ▼
2. Humphrey, D., Willesson, M., Bergendahl, G., Lindblom, T. (2006, June). Benefits from a changing payment technology in European banking. Journal of Banking & Finance, 30: 6, 1631-1652. doi.org/10.1016/j.jbankfin.2005.09.009
3. Saunders, A., Scholnick, B. (2006, June). Frontiers in payment and settlement systems: Introduction. Journal of Banking & Finance,30: 6, 1605-1612. doi.org/10.1016/j.jbankfin.2005.09.007
4. Schmiedel, H. (2004). Performance of international securities markets. Bank of Finland Studies. Retrieved from helda.helsinki.fi/bof/bitstream/handle/123456789/9363/113206.pdf?sequence= 1&isAllowed =y
5. Tereschenko, H.M. (2007). Problems of formation and guidelines for improvement of functioning of the securities market in Ukraine. Finansy Ukrainy – Finance of Ukraine, 6, 97-104 [in Ukrainian].
6. Holovko, A.T. Laptiev, S.M., Kabanov, V.H. (2009). Financial instruments markets and their infrastructure. Kyiv: University of Economics and Law "KROK" [in Ukrainian].
7. Oparin, V., Fedosov, V., L'ovochkin, S. et al. (2016). Financial infrastructure of Ukraine: condition, problems and development prospects. Kyiv: KNEU. 695 c. [in Ukrainian].
8. Rekunenko, I.I. (2013). Infrastructure of Ukraine’s financial market: current status and development prospects. Sumy: DVNZ "UABS NBU". Retrieved from essuir.sumdu.edu.ua/handle/123456789/5007 [in Ukrainian].
9. Stasinevych, S.A. (2015). Improving the depository security of Ukraine’s securities market. Finansovyj prostir – Financial space, 1 (17), 267-271. Retrieved from nbuv.gov.ua/UJRN/Fin_pr_2015_1_36 [in Ukrainian].
10. Drobiazko, A.O. (2020). Subordination of the levels of financial infrastructure and tools of the banking segment. Finansy Ukrainy – Finance of Ukraine, 8, 5-10. doi.org/10.33763/finukr2020.08.103 [in Ukrainian].
11. Moshenskyj, S.Z. (2010). Securities market: transformation processes. Moscow: Jekonomika [in Russian].
12. Majorov, S.Y. (2015). Clearing in financial markets. Moscow: IIC "Statistika Rossii" [in Russian].
13. Securities Settlement Systems in Poland and the European Union (2009). The National Bank of Poland, The National Depository for Securities SA, The Warsaw Stock Exchange. Warsaw. Retrieved from www.nbp.pl/en/system_platniczy/securities_settlement_systems.pdf
14. The concept of reform of Ukraine’s capital market infrastructure, approved by the decision of the NSSMC, No 740 of 26.10.2018. Retrieved from www.nssmc.gov.ua/documents/kontseptsya-reformi-nfrastrukturi-rinkv-kaptalu-v-ukran/ [in Ukrainian].
15. Principles for Financial Market infrastructures (2012, April). Committee on Payment and Settlement Systems, Technical Committee of the International Organization of Securities Commissions. Basel. Retrieved from www.bis.org/cpmi/publ/d101a.pdf
16. Core Principles for Systemically Important Payment Systems (2001, January). Committee on Payment and Settlement Systems. Basel. Retrieved from www.bis.org/cpmi/publ/d43.pdf
17. Recommendations for Securities Settlement Systems (2001, November). Committee on Payment and Settlement Systems, Technical Committee of the International Organization of Securities Commissions. Basel. Retrieved from www.bis.org/cpmi/publ/d42.pdf
18. Shyshkov, S.Ye. (2011). Ukraine’s stock exchanges: a crisis test. Institute for Economics and Forecasting, NAS of Ukraine. Kyiv: Vydavnychyj dim "Kyievo-Mohylians'ka akademiia" [in Ukrainian].
19. Antonov, S.M., Shyshkov, S.Ye. (2014, 29 August). Financial infrastructure: the problems of underdevelopment. Dzerkalo tyzhnia. Ukraina – The mirror of the week. Ukraine. Retrieved from dt.ua/finances/finansova-infrastruktura-problemi-nedorozvitku-_.html [in Ukrainian].
20. Banque de France (2018). Payments and market infrastructures in the digital era. Retrieved from publications.banque-france.fr/sites/default/files/media/2019/06/28/ 819029_livre_paiements_ infrastructures_en_v3.pdf
21. Wyman, Oliver. (2015). Securities Services: The Good Times Are Over, It Is Time To Act. Retrieved from www.oliverwyman.com/content/dam/oliver-wyman/global/en/2015/jun/Securities_ Services_2015.pdf
22. Deloitte Tax & Consulting (2019). The evolution of a core financial service: Custodian & Depositary Banks. Retrieved from www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/lu/Documents/ financial-services/lu-the-evolution-of-a-core-financial-service.pdf
23. Law of Ukraine of 19.06.2020 No 738-IX "On Amendments to Various Laws of Ukraine on the Simplification of Attracting Investments and Introduction of New Financial Instruments". Retrieved from zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/738-20#Text [in Ukrainian].
Events calendar
M | T | W | T | F | S | S |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | 2 | 3 | ||||
4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 |
18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 |
25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | 31 |