НА ГЛАВНУЮ | |
№ 2022/1
1НИФИ ГУНУ "Академия финансового управления"
THE BENCHMARK FOR VAT AND VAT EXPENDITURES IN UKRAINE: METHODOLOGICAL AND PRAGMATIC ASPECTS
Ekon. prognozuvannâ 2022; 1:78-106 | https://doi.org/10.15407/eip2022.01.078 |
АННОТАЦИЯ ▼
Despite the preparation by the State Tax Service of Ukraine of Reports on tax reliefs that are a loss of budget revenues, which indicate certain steps towards the introduction of the concept of tax expenditures in the budget process, the question of their quality remains open due to the uncertainty of the principles of distribution of tax reliefs into those that are losses of budget revenues and other tax reliefs, and due to the algorithm for calculating budget losses from the provision of tax reliefs. In view of the above, the purpose of the article is to determine methodological approaches to the formation of Directories and, accordingly, Reports of the State Tax Service of Ukraine on tax reliefs (on the example of VAT reliefs), that are losses of budget revenues, and on other tax reliefs and justification of the guidelines for improving the quality of such reports.
Based on the analysis of concepts of benchmark tax system (tax) and tax expenditure and approaches to determining their main elements, the author formulates requirements for the structure of Directories of tax reliefs and Reports on tax reliefs, in particular, it is established that if the Directory of tax reliefs, which are losses of budget revenues should include only tax expenditures, then in the structure of the Directory of other tax incentives two components can be distinguished – "structural incentives", which are elements of the benchmark tax system, and special incentives that do not lead to the loss of budgetary revenues. In order to facilitate the identification and analysis, the main components of "structural VAT reliefs" in Ukraine, as well as types (groups) of reliefs that do not cause budget losses are identified, cases of unjustified classification of tax reliefs in the State Tax Service Directories are considered and proposals to change their classification are substantiated. Based on the calculations, it was identified which groups of reliefs predominate in the system of other reliefs, as well as in the reliefs that are losses of budget revenues.
According to the results of the study, it was concluded that the amount of "structural reliefs" of VAT in Ukraine is 4.5 times higher than the amount of tax expenditures, which, if necessary, can be considered as a reserve for increasing tax revenues to the state budget of Ukraine. The shortcomings of the systematic accounting of VAT reliefs in the Directories of tax reliefs have been identified and proposals aimed at improving the correctness and completeness of their accounting have been developed.
Ключевые слова:benchmark tax system; tax expenditures, "structural reliefs", VAT reliefs, tax reliefs accounting, Directories of tax reliefs
Статья на украинском языке (cтр. 78 - 106) | Загрузить | Загрузок : 202 |
ПЕРЕЧЕНЬ ЛИТЕРАТУРЫ ▼
2. Global tax expenditures database. URL: gted.net/country-profile
3. Redonda A., Von Haldenwang C. Tax expenditures: The hidden side of government spending. VoxEU. 16 June 2021. URL: voxeu.org/article/tax-expenditures-hidden-side-government-spending
4. Постанова Кабінету Міністрів України "Порядок обліку сум податків і зборів, не сплачених суб'єктом господарювання до бюджету у зв'язку з отриманням податкових пільг" №1233 від 27.12.2010. URL: zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1233-2010-%D0%BF#Text
5. Heady C., Mansour М. Tax Expenditure Reporting and Its Use in Fiscal Management: A Guide for Developing Economies / International Monetary Fund. 2019. URL: www.imf.org/en/Publications/Fiscal-Affairs-Department-How-To-Notes/Issues/2019/03/27/Tax-Expenditure-Reporting-and-Its-Use-in-Fiscal-Management-A-Guide-for-Developing-Economies-46676
6. Sugin L. Tax Expenditure Analysis and Constitutional Decisions. 1998. Р. 408–474. URL: ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/faculty_scholarship/57/
7. Fleming J.C., Peroni R.J. Can Tax Expenditure Analysis Be Divorced from a Normative Tax Base: A Critique of the "New Paradigm" and its Denouement. Virginia Tax Review. 2010. Vol. 30. P. 135–180. URL: papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1674544
8. Palisi P. Tax expenditure analysis - origins, debates and future prospects. 2017. URL: treasury.gov.au/publication/tax-expenditure-analysis-origins-debates-and-future-prospects
9. Altshuler R., Dietz R.D. Tax expenditure estimation and reporting: A critical review. NBER Working Paper 14263. 2008. URL: papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1248924;
doi.org/10.3386/w14263
10. Burman, L.E., Phaup, M. (2011). Tax expenditures, the size and efficiency of government, and implications for budget reform. NBER Working Paper 17268. Retrieved from www.urban.org/sites/default/ files/publication/27696/413130-Tax-Expenditures-the-Size-and-Efficiency-of-Government-and-Implications-for-Budget-Reform.PDF;
doi.org/10.3386/w17268
11. Craig J., Allan W. Fiscal Transparency, Tax Expenditures, and Budget Processes: An International Perspective. NTA Papers and Proceedings. 2002. URL: www.estimacionestributarias.com/archivos/ Gastos%20tributarios.%20Craig%20and%20Allan.pdf
12. Kraan D.-J. Off-budget and tax expenditures. OECD Journal on Budgeting. 2004. №4(1). Р. 121–142. URL: www.oecd.org/gov/budgeting/39515114.pdf;
doi.org/10.1787/budget-v4-art6-en
13. Laporte В., Caldeira Е., C. de Quatrebarbes, Bouterige Y. Tax Expenditure Assessment: From Principles to Practice. Methodological guide. 2018. URL: ferdi.fr/dl/df-PSDXZuxEEh8LihnEhHUoFkjx/ tax-expenditure-assessment-from-principles-to-practice-methodological-guide.pdf
14. Hashimzade N., Heady C., Myles G., Oats L., Scharf K., Yousefi H. The Definition, Measurement, and Evaluation of Tax Expenditures and Tax Reliefs. Technical paper prepared for the National Audit Office. 2014. URL: ore.exeter.ac.uk/repository/bitstream/handle/10871/16391/TARC_Tax_Expenditures_and_tax_reliefs_09-07-14.pdf?sequence=2&isAllowed=y
15. Villela L., Lemgruber А., Jorratt М. Tax Expenditure Budgets. Concepts and Challenges for Implementation. Inter-American Development Bank. IDB Working Paper Series. 2010. IDB-WP-131. URL: idbdocs.iadb.org/wsdocs/getdocument.aspx?docnum=35170590
16. Burton, M., Stewart, M. Promoting budget transparency through tax expenditure management: a report on country experience for civil society advocates. Melbourne Law School Legal Studies Research Paper. 2011. №544. URL: poseidon01.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID= 293089090070115014031064014031089098004008058002025032090123114097083028086080091112122000022099013026035123090082093085117069059076021059086066092015024092102126077047095008089029020090107111066127020109113005072094065097068010098118119102008084024&EXT=pdf&INDEX=TRUE;
doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1864324
17. Kassim L., Mansour М. Tax expenditures reporting in developing countries: An evaluation. Revue d'économie du développement. 2018. Vol. 26. Is. 2. URL: www.cairn-int.info/article-E_EDD_322_0113--tax-expenditures-reporting-in.htm
18. Tax Expenditures in OECD Countries / OECD. 2010. URL: www.ciat.org/Biblioteca/AreasTematicas/Economia/GastoTributario/2010_tax_expenditure_countries_oecd.pdf; doi.org/10.1787/9789264076907-en
19. Система податкових пільг в Україні в контексті європейського досвіду / Соколовська А.М., Єфименко Т.І., Луніна І.О. та ін. Київ: НДФІ, 2006. 320 с.
20. Налоговые льготы. Теория и практика применения: монография для магистрантов / [И.А. Майбуров и др.]; под ред. И.А. Майбурова, Ю.Б. Иванова. Москва: ЮНИТИ-ДАНА, 2014. 487 с.
21. Майбуров И. Оценка налоговых расходов и эффективности налоговых льгот: методология решения задачи. Общество и экономика. 2013. №4. С. 71–91. URL: elibrary.ru/item.asp?id=19132879
22. Соколовська А.М., Петраков Я.В. Концепція податкових витрат та шляхи її застосування в Україні. Фінанси України. 2013. №11. С. 23–44. URL: finukr.org.ua/?page_id=723&aid=639
23. Иванов Ю., Майбуров И., Назаренко А. Методологические основы оценки и моделирования эффективности налоговых льгот. Общество и экономика. 2016. №10. С. 80–96.
24. Surrey S., McDaniel P.R. The Tax Expenditure Concept: Current Developments And Emerging Issues. 1979. Vol. 20. Is. 2. №2. Р. 225–369. URL: lawdigitalcommons.bc.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1605&context= bclr
25. OECD. Best Practice Guidelines – Off Budget and Tax Expenditures. 25th Annual Meeting of Senior Budget Official. 2004. URL: www.resourcegovernance.org/sites/default/files/OECD%20Off-Budget%20&%20Tax%20Expenditures%20Guidelines.pdf
26. Chapman L.F., McKenzie K., Porter S., Lindsay T. Tax Policy Forum: Review of Tax Expenditures, Budget 2016. MPRA Paper № 96926. July 2017. URL: mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/96926/1/MPRA_paper_ 96926.pdf
27. Caiumi A. The Evaluation of the Effectiveness of Tax Expenditures – A Novel Approach: An Application to the Regional Tax Incentives for Business Investments in Italy. OECD Taxation Working Papers. 2011. URL: www.researchgate.net/publication/254439340_The_Evaluation_ of_the_Effectiveness_of_Tax_Expenditures_-_A_Novel_Approach_An_ Application_to_the_Regional_Tax_Incentives_for_Business_Investments_in_Italy/link/5facfed4a6fdcc9389ab4629/download
28. Наказ ДПА України Держкомстату України "Правила обліку податку на додану вартість для вдосконалення обчислення вартісної величини впливу пільг з цього податку на формування дохідної частини Державного бюджету України" № 419/453 від 23.07.2004. URL: zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/z0939-04/ed20040723#Text
29. De La Feria R., Krever R. Ending VAT Exemptions: Towards a Post-Modern VAT. VAT Exemptions: Consequences and Design Alternatives. Wolters Kluwer, 2013. Р. 3–36. URL: www.researchgate.net/publication/ 303863105_Ending_VAT_Exemptions_Towards_a_Post-Modern_VAT
30. Податкова гармонізація в Україні в умовах реалізації Угоди про асоціацію між Україною і ЄС: монографія / за ред. А.М. Соколовської; ДННУ "Акад. фін. управління". Київ, 2017. 448 с. URL: afu.kiev.ua/getfile.php?page_id=458&num=1;
doi.org/10.15407/eip2017.02.093
Календарь событий
Пн | Вт | Ср | Чт | Пт | Сб | Вс |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 |
8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 |
15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 |
22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 |
29 | 30 | 31 |