HOME PAGE | |
№ 2016/1
1Institute for Economics and Forecasting, NAS of Ukraine
Regularities in the formation of conjuncture and manipulations of the 'invisible hand' on the oil market
Ekon. prognozuvannâ 2016; 1:95-116 | https://doi.org/10.15407/eip2016.01.095 |
ABSTRACT ▼
The author has made a retrospective structural and institutional analysis of the world oil market. Periods were selected as well as five stages of the institutional structure of the oil market. The first phase (1859-1947) is characterized by relatively stable prices for raw materials based on the "one-base price system" controlled by the international oil cartel, which included the largest petroleum companies in the world, so-called "seven sisters." The second phase (1947-1971) is associated with the transition to the "two-base price system" with an increase in oil supplies from the Middle East. The third phase (1971-1985) is characterized by the end of the period of concession agreements, nationalization of deposits and transition to the cartel impact on price indices. Fourth stage (1985-2005) is characterized by the transition to stock market based oil trade, rising volatility and the development of risk management mechanisms. And the fifth stage (since 2005) is characterized by the dominance of financial instruments in the global oil trade.
Based on the results of the factor analysis, the article reveals the main components that determine the situation and price dynamics during the recent phase of the oil market. Beginning with the middle of the first decade of XXI century, the oil futures market became segment of the monetary market instead of an independent commodity market whose conditions depend on the relationship between demand and supply, stocks of marketable goods and investments in the development of oil extraction. That is why the correlation of the quotations of oil futures with the dollar/euro ratios and other purely financial factors is so strong.
The author considers essential features of the oil crises and the etymology of the term of "energy crisis." Currently, the researchers have only agreed to identify the first and second oil (energy) crises which had global implications and a marked impact on the world economic development. It is established that their essential feature was creation of an artificial shortage of oil supply on the cartel dominated market due to political factors. Instead, changes in the structure of the oil market and the rapid rise in prices in the middle of the first decade of this century gives reason to identify a third world energy crisis through the creation of an artificial surplus demand through the use of financial instruments. On this basis, a concept of "energy crisis", which unlike existing contains quantitative criteria (proportion) of price changes in the dominant primary energy resource balance.
The article deals with the influence of the factor of "resource curse" on the economic dynamics and gives various examples of overcoming the "Dutch disease." In economic terms, resource wealth has a decisive impact on the economic dynamics of exporters. Only a few countries have ever managed to loosen this dependence by deregulating and liberalizing the energy markets, and by diversifying the use of the super-profits. The high correlation between economic growth and oil prices in the countries affected by "Dutch disease" significantly weakens their resistance to low oil prices. So we can assume that the minimum prices on the world oil market are, for such countries, the most striking economic sanctions. And overcoming this situation could be by searching a way to build new geopolitical structures, rather than by developing a more rational economic policy.
The author assesses the impact of global conjuncture on the development of Ukraine's domestic oil products market. Significant reduction in world oil prices made almost no impact on Ukraine's consumer market of oil products, since it coincided with the devaluation of the national currency and introduction at the beginning of 2016 of the new excise rates on fuel sales. When the government has no effective levers to regulate the market (similar to an influential national vertically integrated oil company or strategic stocks of oil/oil products) it tries to influence the market through fiscal authorities, which only makes it possible to identify certain abuses committed by oil traders (in the form of unfair competition). And the state system of market surveillance for the quality of oil as an instrument of the new system of technical regulation is not working because of the inspections moratorium, which is part of the reforms aimed at economic deregulation.
The study made various forecast based assumptions regarding the development of the conjuncture on the oil market. An important practical result of the study is justification for the fact that presently, against the background of the divergences in the export policy among the OPEC countries, the interests of the largest oil-importing and oil exporting countries largely coincide. This situation once again brings the conjuncture of oil market in the zone of turbulence. Both exporters and importers are concerned that the oil price stay within a certain corridor, whose lower limit ensures the exporters sufficient export revenues to maintain and increase oil production for their sustainable development, and whose upper limit does not prevent sustainable economic growth in developed countries and the global economy.
Keywords: oil market, structural and institutional analysis, conjuncture, pricing mechanism, energy crisis, factor analysis, derivatives
JEL: D40, L11, N70
Article in Ukrainian (pp. 95 - 116) | Download | Downloads :1243 |
REFERENCES ▼
2. Tad, Patzek (2006). The Hubbert Peaks. University of Wisconsin, Madison, October 6.
3. Yergin, Daniel (2016). The Prize: The Epic Quest for Oil, Money, and Power. Moscow: Alpina Publisher [in Russian].
4. Chevalier, J.-M. (1975). Oil Crisis. Moscow: Progress [in Russian].
5. Tugendhat, C. Hamilton, A. (1978). Oil the biggest business. Moscow: Progress [in Russian].
6. Konoplyanik, A. (2000). The world oil market: the return the era of low prices? RAS Institute of economic forecasting. Moscow: Publishing house of IEF [in Russian].
7. Zhukov, S. Kopitin, I., Maslennikov, A. (2012). Integration of the oil and financial markets and shifts in pricing for oil. RAS Institute of economic forecasting. Moscow: Publishing house of the IEF [in Russian].
8. Makarenko, I. (2007). Economic dynamics of the global economy in 2007. The forecast of IEE, 4 (60). Retrieved from iee.org.ua/ua/detailed/prognoz/762 [in Russian].
9. The IMF does not expect a tangible influence the growth of oil prices on the global economy (2007). Business. Retrieved May 25, 2007, from delo.ua/news/economics/world/info-35205.html [in Russian].
10. Oil prices and the growth of the world economy. Project Syndicate, USA. Retrieved from 24news.com.ua/6765-ceny-na-neft-i-rost-mirovoj-ekonomiki/ [in Russian].
11. Energy Charter Secretariat (2007). The price of energy. International pricing mechanisms for oil and gas. Retrieved from www.nauka.x-pdf.ru/17energetika [in Russian].
12. Milovidov, K. (2006). Trends in the global oil and gas business. Moscow: Publishing house of IEF [in Russian].
13. Peremitin, G. (2016). Leaving oil revenues: how exporting countries respond to the reduction in income. RBK. Retrieved January 19, 2016, from www.rbc.ru/economics/19/01/2016 [in Russian].
14. Skrybka, E. (2016). Oil budgets. Oil market, 01–02 (930–931), 21 [in Russian].
15. Dobronravin, N., Margania, O. (eds.) (2008). Oil, Gas, and Society Modernization. St. Petersburg: Economic school [in Russian].
16. Mosyenko, D. (2015). Cheap oil: myths and realities. The causes and consequences of low oil prices. EnergoBusiness, 5 (894), 4–7 [in Russian].
17. A record falling oil prices: if petrol will become cheaper in Ukraine and what will happen with the ruble (2016). Today. Retrieved January 6, 2016, from www.segodnya.ua/economics/enews.html [in Russian].
18. Ryabtsev, G., Sapegin, S., Lir, V. (2008). Oil products in Ukraine: Present and Future. Kyiv: PE "Sanspareil", 139, 217–222 [in Russian].
19. State Reserve wants to create a stock 2 million tons of oil (2015). Oil market, 46 (925), 21 [in Russian].
20. The EU will provide Ukraine with 12 million Euros for the creation of a stock of oil and oil products and improve fuel quality (2016). Oil market, 3 (932), 10 [in Russian].
21. Why Iran and Saudi Arabia is beneficial cheap oil (2016). Retrieved from www.rbc.ru/newspaper/2016/01/22 [in Russian].
22. The demand for oil in 2015-2020 will grow (2015). Oil market, 06 (885), 28 [in Russian].
Events calendar
M | T | W | T | F | S | S |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | ||||||
2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 |
16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 |
23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 |
30 |